From the Future Doc YouTube channel · Recorded 1 November 2026 · 9 min video
Mostly, no. The big gaps you see between medical schools in postgraduate exam results are largely explained by the students those schools select, not by what happens once they arrive, and research on patient outcomes found no difference in mortality based on where a doctor trained. Teaching style has a small effect, but what predicts your outcome is you, so the real priority is getting in somewhere.
Key takeaways
- Treat medical school league tables with caution: they mostly measure the students a school takes in, not what the school adds.
- Don’t read group averages as your personal odds. How hard you work at medical school and beyond matters far more.
- Use teaching style as a genuine reason to choose. If you like structure, a heavily self-directed course might not suit you, and vice versa.
- Pick a university in a city where you’ll thrive. Your wellbeing will affect your performance more than any strategic choice of school.
- Put your energy into getting in. Everyone leaves with the same medical degree, and getting a place is the real bottleneck.
What’s changed since this video
This video was recorded in November 2026. Most of the advice still stands, but note:
- Application statistics change every cycle. Figures mentioned in this video were correct at the time of recording.
- Most of the medical school comparison data discussed in the video is 10 to 20 years old, and medical schools have changed their courses since. Foundation Programme allocation rules can also change, so check the current process when you get there.
Where does the 91% versus 32% figure come from?
91% first time pass rate versus 32% first time pass rate. That is the gap in how many graduates passed a really difficult postgraduate exam first time, depending on which medical school they came from. 91% from Oxford. 32% from Liverpool.
If you’re worried about whether your university will shape your future career, that number looks terrifying. I had a sneaky suspicion it might be misleading, so I made a cup of tea before clinic and dug into the research.
First, here’s the problem with comparing medical schools. Every medical school sets its own exams and its own standards, so you can’t really compare one with another. Once you reach postgraduate level, though, the exams are national and standardised. If you want to become a hospital physician, for example, you sit the MRCP, the Membership of the Royal College of Physicians exam. That means we can compare who passes first time.
In 2008, a UCL professor called Chris McManus had the clever idea of comparing those results based on where each doctor graduated. He looked at around 6,000 doctors from 19 UK medical schools who sat the MRCP between 2003 and 2005. The gap was huge. Over twice as many Newcastle graduates passed first time compared with Liverpool graduates. McManus put it bluntly: not all medical schools are equal.
So case closed? If you don’t go to Oxford, there’s no point bothering? Not quite.
Do league tables measure the medical school or the students it picks?
The study didn’t ask one really key question. Who entered these universities in the first place?
Oxford and Cambridge take some of the highest attaining students in the country. Those students then go on to do well in exams. Is that because of the teaching, or were they always going to do well?
The philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein had an idea known as Wittgenstein’s ruler. If you can’t trust the ruler, you don’t know what’s doing the measuring. Is the ruler measuring the table, or is the table measuring the ruler? League tables claim to measure the schools. If the students are different on day one, they’re really measuring the type of student each university picks.
McManus tested this. He adjusted for each student’s grades before they started medical school, and about 60% of the difference between medical schools was explained by pre-admission qualifications alone. Most of the gap was there before anyone had sat a single lecture.
For surgery, the picture is even clearer. When researchers looked at the Membership of the Royal College of Surgeons exam, the MRCS, pass rates differed between schools again. Once they accounted for A-level performance, the difference vanished completely. For surgery, your medical school made no detectable difference at all.
Why the effect of selection is probably bigger than 60%
Honestly, I think the real effect of selection is bigger than that 60%.
Almost everyone applying to medicine has straight A’s and is a high achiever. A-levels can’t really tell a very strong student apart from an exceptional one, so controlling for them doesn’t tell the whole story.
On top of that, Oxford and Cambridge in particular used to set additional admissions tests. Those tests separate the very good from the cream of the crop, and that’s exactly who they were selecting. The studies didn’t account for any of that.
Does teaching style at medical school make a difference?
A little. In 2020, McManus and a large team ran the biggest study yet, called MedDifs. They pooled 50 measures across 29 UK medical schools, looking at things like entry grades, teaching style, specialty choice, exam results and fitness to practise cases. They found three things.
- Teaching style matters a bit. Problem-based learning schools did worse on postgraduate exams. Lower entry grades explained some of that, but not all of it.
- Happy students don’t necessarily get better results. Schools where students rated their feedback more highly did worse in later exams. Feeling supported and being stretched aren’t the same thing. Maybe universities like Cardiff, where I went, with a bit of tough love, help you become stronger and more independent in the long run.
- Self-directed learning helps. Schools where students did more self-regulated learning had better postgraduate results.
So what a school is like does have a small effect. It’s nothing compared with the effect of selection.
And just so I’m not unfair to Liverpool: most of this data is 10 or 20 years old. Liverpool, for example, has moved away from pure PBL. Schools change. If you want to know what problem-based learning actually involves, I’ve written about what to expect from PBL and how to excel at it.
Does your medical school affect your first job as a doctor?
Postgraduate exams are one thing. Most people really want to know how their medical school affects where they’ll end up working. So let’s look at the Foundation Programme, your first job as a doctor.
Until recently, you were ranked by the decile you finished in at your school, which gave you a number of points, plus a situational judgement test sat nationally. You got ten points if you were in the top decile and one point if you were in the bottom decile, or something equivalent. Those points were the same whether you went to Oxford or to one of the less competitive medical schools. So your choice of school didn’t matter there.
Now the system has changed even further, to what’s been called the happiness algorithm. You rank your preferences and a computer allocates places to please as many people as possible.
What’s interesting is that since the 2024/25 academic year, graduates from every medical school sit the same exit exam, the UKMLA. For the first time, there’s a standardised exam comparing everybody from every medical school just as they’re about to graduate.
For more on what comes after your degree, have a look at what happens after medical school.
Can patients tell where their doctor trained?
This is the most important question of all, because the job is about patients.
We have some research from the US, where medical school prestige is a big deal. In 2018, researchers looked at nearly a million hospital admissions and more than 30,000 doctors, and compared patient outcomes against the ranking of each doctor’s medical school.
The result? Absolutely zero difference in 30-day mortality. There was a slight difference in readmission rates and in the amount of money spent. Your patients can’t tell where you trained.
What this means when you're choosing a medical school
So, back to that 91% versus 32%. What can we actually conclude?
- League tables measure intake more than outcomes. They tell you more about who a school selects than about what it does for its students.
- These are averages, not your individual odds. There’s a well known mistake called the ecological fallacy: drawing conclusions about an individual from data about the group they belong to. Group statistics don’t automatically apply to you. You can study harder for those exams. You can work harder in your career. If you know how to play the game and you work really hard, you can turn the odds massively in your favour.
- What predicts your outcome is you.
- Teaching style is a valid reason to choose. If you like structured learning, a self-directed course might not suit you, and vice versa. My guide on which medical school teaching style suits you best will help you work that out.
- Getting in somewhere matters more than where. We all leave with the same medical degree and the same opportunities. Where you take your career from there is down to you.
That’s why I always say choosing a university in a city where you’ll thrive is far more likely to affect your outcome than any strategic choice about where it will take your career. Your wellbeing feeds your performance. So you can rest assured on that one.
The hard part is getting in. That’s the bottleneck. Put your energy there, and when it comes to picking where to apply, use a clear strategy for choosing your medical schools rather than chasing a league table. If you’d like help making sure you get a place, that’s exactly what the Future Doc programme is for.
Frequently asked questions
Does it matter which medical school you go to?
Much less than league tables suggest. Research by Chris McManus found that about 60% of the difference in postgraduate exam pass rates between medical schools was explained by students’ qualifications before they started, and for the surgical MRCS exam the difference disappeared completely once A-level performance was accounted for. Everyone graduates with the same medical degree.
Do Oxford and Cambridge graduates do better as doctors?
Their graduates have had higher first time pass rates in some postgraduate exams, but that’s largely because these universities select some of the highest attaining students in the country. The students were likely to do well regardless. A US study of nearly a million hospital admissions found zero difference in 30-day patient mortality based on the ranking of a doctor’s medical school.
Is problem-based learning worse than traditional teaching?
The MedDifs study found that problem-based learning schools did worse on postgraduate exams, and lower entry grades only explained part of that. The effect was small compared with selection, and much of the data is old. Schools change their courses, so choose the teaching style that suits how you learn.
Will my medical school affect which Foundation job I get?
Under the older system, you got points based on your decile within your own school plus a national situational judgement test, so the school itself didn’t give you an advantage. The system has since moved to an algorithm based on your ranked preferences. Since the 2024/25 academic year, all medical students also sit the same exit exam, the UKMLA.
Want help with your application?
The Predictable Offer Protocol is Future Doc’s complete programme for medicine and dentistry applicants, with one coach coordinating every part of your application.
Video transcript
Transcript from “Does Your Medical School Actually Matter? (The Data Says…)” (1 November 2026)
91%. First time pass rate versus 32%. First time pass rate. That is the difference in the percentages of graduates from medical school who pass a really difficult postgraduate exam first time, depending on which medical school they graduated from. 91% being from Oxford Medical School.
32% being from Liverpool Medical School. Now, if you're worried about whether your university affects your future career prospects, that number might be terrifying, but I have a sneaky suspicion that that number might be misleading. So I've got a bit of time before clinic starts. I've made a cup of tea, I'm going to do some research, and we're going to dig into the question of does the medical school you go to affect your career prospects? So firstly, here's the problem with comparing medical schools.
Every medical school sets their own exams. They have their own standards. So you can't really compare one to the other. However, when you hit postgraduate level, the exams are nationalised and standardised. So for example, if you take people who want to become a hospital physician.
They will sit the MRCP, the Membership of the Royal College of Physicians exam, and then we can compare data between who pass first time, etc.. So in 2008, a UCL professor called Chris McManus had a clever idea of comparing the results based on where that person graduated. He looked at around 6000 doctors from 19 UK medical schools who sat the MRCP between the years of 2003 and 2005. So, as you can see from this table of first time pass rates, the gap was huge. For example, if you take Newcastle Medical School, over twice as many people passed first time compared to those who graduated from Liverpool Medical School.
McManus himself put it quite bluntly. Not all medical schools are equal. So case closed, right? If you don't go to Oxford, then there's no point in bothering. But one of the things that they did not ask about this study was a really key question is who entered these universities in the first place?
Oxford and Cambridge takes some of the highest attaining students in the country, then those students go on to do well in exams. Is that because of the teaching, or because they were always going to do well by the nature of the people going to those universities? There's an idea from the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein called Wittgenstein's Ruler that says, if you can't trust the ruler that is measuring, then you don't know what's doing the measuring. Is the ruler measuring the table, or is the table measuring the ruler. So these league tables are claiming to measure the schools, but if the students that they picked are different on day one, it's really more a measure of the type of students that those universities pick.
And McManus actually tested this. He adjusted for each student's grades before they started medical school, and about 60% of the difference between medical schools was explained by pre admissions qualifications alone. Most of the gap was there before anyone had had a single lecture at medical school. When we looked at it like this, there's another postgraduate exam where this difference completely disappears. So if we look at the surgical equivalent, the Membership of the Royal College of Surgeons exam, the MRCS.
This completely changed. The pass rates differed between schools again, but once researchers accounted for the A-level performance, the difference vanished completely. So for surgery, your school made no detectable difference at all. And honestly, the real effect of selection is probably bigger than the 60%, because all people applying to medical schools generally have straight A's and are high achieving students. A-levels can't really distinguish between a very strong student and an exceptional one, so even controlling for that doesn't tell the whole story.
And here's the thing the real effect of selection is probably even bigger than 60%, because when you think about it, Oxford and Cambridge especially previously used to do additional admissions tests, which distinguishes between the very good and the cream of the crop which they are selecting. So that is something that the studies didn't look at. So what is it that's making that difference? Well, McManus repeated a similar study in 2020 and had a large team that ran the biggest study yet, called MedDifs, and they pooled 50 measures across 29 UK medical schools. And they looked at things like entry grades, teaching style, speciality choice, exam results and fitness to practice cases.
Right. And they find three things. Number one, the teaching style does matter a little bit. For example, problem based learning schools did worse on postgraduate exams and lower entry grades explained some of that, but not all of it. The second thing they found is that happy students don't necessarily make for better results.
So schools where students rated their feedback more highly did worse in later exams, so feeling supported and being stretched aren't the same thing. Maybe the universities like Cardiff, where I went to have a bit of tough love, probably help you be a bit stronger and more independent in the long run. And third, self-directed learning help. So schools where students did more self-regulated learning had better postgraduate results. So what the school is like does have a small effect, but nothing compared to the selection of students that we talked about earlier.
And just to not crap on Liverpool that this data is, you know, 10 or 20 years old mostly. And for example, Liverpool, they've moved away from pure PBL. So schools change. So again this is what I want to come and talk to you later when we talk about how it affects you individually. So that's all well and good for postgraduate exams.
But people want to know how it affects where you'll end up working as a doctor. So let's take Foundation training, your first job as a doctor and how that is affected. Well, until recently they used to have a system where you were ranked by the decile you come in in your school, and that will give you a number of points, as well as a situational judgement test, which was done nationally. Now that combination would rank you and then you'd get to choose based on that. But that really doesn't matter what medical school you go to, because you get ten points if you're in the top decile, one point if you're in the bottom decile or something equivalent, and you get those same points regardless of whether you went to Oxford or whether you went to one of the less competitive medical schools.
But now they've changed the system even further to something called the happiness algorithm, where you rank your preferences and then they computer generate it at random to give you what ideally pleases the most people as much as possible. However, what's interesting is, since the 2024/25 academic year, those who graduated of all across all medical schools been asked to do the same exit exam, which is the UKMLA. So that means the first time will have a standardised exam that compares everybody from every medical school as they about to graduate from their university. So what about the most important thing which is patients? Well, we have some research from the US where school prestige is a big deal.
Researchers in 2018 looked into nearly a million hospital admissions and more than 30,000 doctors, and compared patient outcomes against the ranking of each doctor's medical school. The result? Absolutely zero difference in 30 day mortality. There was a slight difference in readmissions rate and the amount of money spent. But it turns out that your patients can't tell where you trained.
So what does this actually mean for you? When we looked at that 91 versus 32%. What conclusions can we draw from that? Firstly, remember that number one, the league tables measure intake more than really the outcomes generated by the medical schools. Number two remember that these are averages.
They do not signify your individual odds. There's a well known phenomenon called the ecological fallacy. That's the mistake of drawing conclusions about an individual from the data about the group they belong to. In other words, just because there are group statistics doesn't mean they apply to you individually. As a student, for example, those exams, you can study harder.
You can work harder in your career. You really can turn any statistical odds massively in your favour by knowing how to play the game and working really hard. Which brings me on to number three, which is what predicts your outcome is you number four. Is that a teaching style is a valid criteria to make your choice on if you like structured learning. A self-directed course might not suit you and vice versa.
And number five remember, the most important thing is that what matters is getting in somewhere rather than where we all leave with the same medical degree, the same opportunities. And as we've mentioned earlier in this video, it's really down to you for where you take your career and what you make of it. So choosing a university in a city where you're going to thrive is much more likely to affect your well-being, which will help your performance way more than really any strategic choice from where it will take your career. So you can almost rest assured with that. But as I said, getting in is what matters.
That's the bottleneck. That's the hardest part. So if you would like some help with making sure that happens, check out the Future Doc program, where we've had a 93% success rate for a very long time. Now we're getting students into either their chosen university or any medical school that they're hoping for. So thanks for watching and I'll see you in the next video.